Last night, before I got angry at my friends, I had a wonderful dinner at Rigsby's. A dinner that confirmed that I still consider Rigsby's the best restaurant in Columbus. I got there before my family because I went straight from work, so I had a drink at the bar while I waited. I love their new bar, since the renovation at the beginning of the year. The old bar in the back was cozy, but it only seated five so it wasn't especially practical. The new bar has nice deep marble countertops, and a well lit backdrop featuring the wide selection of liquors. The bartender selected decent vodka for me, but the tonic was quite flat. I didn't say anything though since I didn't care that much, otherwise I'm sure he would have taken care of it. Other than the bar, I also like the addition of mirrors in the center of the restaurant. I do not like the renovation of the bathroom, making it into a single bathroom rather than two stalls. I also miss being able to see the food preparation. Overall, it is the exact same, outstanding restaurant. And like usual, Kent Rigsby was wandering the restaurant, making sure everything was perfect and everyone was satisfied.
I started the meal with prosciutto di parma with arugula and fig vinaigrette. Wow. There were four large slices of delicious prosciutto over the arugula, and the vinaigrette complimented the prosciutto perfectly. The waiter didn't mention that there was a menu of Venetian small plates in the center of the table, so we all missed those. I was examining the wine bottle and noticed the menu, so we ordered the deviled eggs, which were made with chopped shallots and other seasonings that made these gourmet enough to be served at a place like Rigsby's - but at only $2, probably the cheapest thing ever served there. My family all enjoyed their antipasti enough not to share, so I didn't get to taste anything else.
For my main dish I got coffee rubbed beef medallions with polenta and something like (but not) roasted pepper dolce, which basically meant roasted red peppers that were kind of sweet and kind of tart. The beef was so, so good. There were two fairly large, extremely thin medallions, coated in a spicy, peppery, flavorful seasoning. The waiter asked me how I wanted it cooked, and although I said medium rare, it was medium, but it didn't matter. It was so thin, that it would have been virtually impossible to make it medium rare, and it was still very, very tender. Usually I'm very picky about how my meat is cooked, so the fact that I didn't mind reflects just how flavorful it was. The polenta was a perfect vehicle for enjoying more of the flavor, and the peppers went perfectly. It is nice that at Rigsby's thought is put into precisely what foods will compliment each other the best. And it is always done artfully.
I also tasted the Mediterranean sea bass, which was nice, but not as good as my beef medallions. The cappellini natasha (spicy cream sauce with salmon), one of the constants on the Rigsby's menu, was the best I have tasted in a long time, with bolder flavors than I remember.
For dessert I had something that I totally can't remember the name of, and couldn't pronounce last night anyway. It had something that meant chocolate upon asking, and orange (or maybe mandarin) in the name. It was an incredibly rich chocolate cake type thing. Actually, it was not cake at all, it was thick chocolaty-ness, like a torte maybe? Or mousse on steroids? I have no idea, but it was good. It was served with a honey like sauce on the plate, dollops of chocolate sauce infused with orange, and these orange gelly things that were awesome. I also tasted the pistachio creme brulee, which was good, but I'm not a creme brulee person. I asked the waiter to select a dessert wine for me, so I had a glass of banyuls with my dessert that was very smooth, and went perfectly with the chocolate.
It was a good birthday dinner.